• RSS

NHL: Will these five prospects make NHL rosters?

Friday, 09.16.2011 / 1:48 PM CT / Training Camp Central
Share with your Friends

NHL: Will these five prospects make NHL rosters?
While it's been nice tracking some of the top young prospects in the various rookie tournaments across North America, we're going to find out a lot more about them – and their chances to earn a big league job – during training camp and the exhibition schedule. After all, they'll be dealing with proven pros, rather than kids, many of whom will never see the light of an NHL rink.

I'll be particularly curious to keep an eye on the pre-season progress of five elite prospects. To get a better handle on their respective games and their chances to make the jump, I reached out to a long-time amateur scout, who has watched these teenagers develop and emerge over the past few years.

Here are his thoughts on my five intriguing prospects. Not to play favorites, I've listed this handful in alphabetical order.

Ryan Ellis, D, Predators (11th overall, 2009)

Despite his size (5-9, 173), the Windsor Spitfires defenseman has been an electric offensive force over the past few seasons in the OHL. One former executive feels he's already among the best power-play trigger men in the world. That's pretty heady praise for a 20-year-old who has yet to play a single game in the NHL.
"Ellis doesn't look like a player until the game starts," says our scout. "Then, you really see it. "He can flat out hammer the puck. He'll play, but I'm not convinced he'll be a star at the NHL level. I think it will depend on whether or not his mobility can support terrific puck skills."
In other words, he feels that Ellis needs to continue to work on his skating. The Predators usually start prospects like Ellis with their AHL affiliate in Milwaukee. I suspect he'll make a stop there before getting a full-time work in Music City.

Ryan Johansen, C, Blue Jackets (4th overall, 2010)

At the 2010 draft in Los Angeles, I ran into Portland Winterhawks GM/Head Coach Mike Johnston. I'd never met him before, but after a few minutes he was singing the praises of his lanky center. Several hours later, Johansen was selected fourth overall by Columbus.

"He's a prototypical top-six NHL center," the scout says. "He's a big kid (6-2, 192) with great reach, hands and vision. "The only question is he ready for the NHL yet? He's still a gangly kid and I think there might be some concern about him getting banged up against the big boys."

With newly acquired Jeff Carter locked in as the Jackets' top center, Johansen could earn the second or third spot with a good camp.

Adam Larsson, D, Devils (4th overall, 2011)

I had a chance to catch the big Swede at the Devils' summer prospect camp in July. Larsson's size (6-3, 220) is impossible to miss, but he also struck me as a pretty mature young guy. He was so eager to have an opportunity to skate in the NHL; he signed an entry-level contract minus the usual bonuses for a prospect of his ilk.

"He's real calm, poised," the scout says. "He's rock solid and he's got upside on both sides of the puck. I see him as the closest kid from the last draft that could play in the NHL."

In New Jersey, Larsson will have the opportunity to learn from Hall of Famer members Larry Robinson and Scott Stevens, who remain as teachers in the organization. I believe Larsson will get every chance to crack the Devils' opening night lineup. In fact, I'm thinking he'll be there.

Ryan Murphy, D, Hurricanes (12th overall, 2011)

The slippery 5-11, 176-pound defenseman wowed pro scouts and execs with his thrilling puck-moving style during the Traverse City rookie tournament earlier in the week. So much so, some feel the Hurricanes have another baby-faced phenom from Kitchener like last season's Calder Trophy winner Jeff Skinner poised to make an immediate impact in the NHL.

"I don't think he's quite ready yet," the scout says. "He's got the tools, though. He can really accelerate with the puck on his stick. He's got a heck of a shot that he gets off without taking a big wind-up and he's got a real short memory. He's not afraid to make mistakes."

Carolina GM Jim Rutherford says Murphy will have every chance to make the team in camp. He did admit that it might be tougher than it was for Skinner because of his position. It's usually harder for a young defenseman to make the jump to the big league than it is for a forward. This year or sometime down the road, Murphy is going to be a player in the Triangle.

Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, C, Oilers (1st overall, 2011)

The top pick in last June's draft hasn't disappointed the Oilers with his play in their rookie games. In fact, as advertised, Nugent-Hopkins has stood head and shoulders above his peers, making one clever, eye-opening play after another.

"He's as skilled and smart as they come," our scout says. "He has great agility that makes him hard to pin down in tight areas of the ice. The only question about him playing this year is his size. He's still a skinny kid, so I think you have to be a little worried about injury."

Another exec is less worried about that problem. "He's really hard to get a good hit on," he says. "If you can't hit him, you can't hurt him."

I'm thinking that Nugent-Hopkins is going to be in an Oilers uniform on opening night. This kid seems like one of those smart young players who'll benefit by playing with his most talented peers.

Author: E.J. Hradek | NHL.com Analyst





1 z - DAL 82 50 23 9 267 230 109
2 x - STL 82 49 24 9 224 201 107
3 x - CHI 82 47 26 9 235 209 103
4 y - ANA 82 46 25 11 218 192 103
5 x - LAK 82 48 28 6 225 195 102
6 x - SJS 82 46 30 6 241 210 98
7 x - NSH 82 41 27 14 228 215 96
8 x - MIN 82 38 33 11 216 206 87
9 COL 82 39 39 4 216 240 82
10 ARI 82 35 39 8 209 245 78
11 WPG 82 35 39 8 215 239 78
12 CGY 82 35 40 7 231 260 77
13 VAN 82 31 38 13 191 243 75
14 EDM 82 31 43 8 203 245 70


F. Forsberg 82 33 31 1 64
R. Josi 81 14 47 -3 61
J. Neal 82 31 27 27 58
S. Weber 78 20 31 -7 51
M. Ribeiro 81 7 43 11 50
C. Smith 82 21 16 4 37
M. Ekholm 82 8 27 14 35
R. Johansen 42 8 26 10 34
R. Ellis 79 10 22 13 32
C. Jarnkrok 81 16 14 1 30
P. Rinne 34 21 10 .908 2.48
C. Hutton 7 5 4 .918 2.33