Transition from Player to Broadcaster

Friday, 09.14.2012 / 1:29 PM

"Once a player always a player" .... so goes the motto of all NHL players past and present. There's a lot of truth to that adage. When you share the same set of experiences with a group of athletes over the course of a very taxing NHL season, you tend to develop a strong bond. It’s a brotherhood. You watch out for one another; you face the same set of challenges day in and day out. In hockey, you literally fight for one another. For every team, even the great ones, there is always adversity and slogging through the adversity together draws you closer as a group.

But when a player leaves the game and he enters the broadcast booth, a different dynamic arises. I would not go so far as to say that the former player's allegiances are torn. But in his new profession, the ex-player has to adopt a more objective perspective. It was something I've gone through the last few years as I joined Tom Callahan in the Preds broadcast booth. Specifically, it comes up in the following type of situation.

A former teammate of mine coughs up the puck in his own zone, the opposition scores and, as a broadcaster, I now need to analyze what I just saw.

There are just two options to choose from in the above scenario. One is to ignore the miscue, focus on the goal scorer's accomplishment, and shield the offending ex-teammate from any criticism in the process. The other option is to call a spade a spade and describe the giveaway that caused the goal. In spite of the fact that it puts a friend in the spotlight for reasons he'd rather not be. In my view, option two is the only option available to a broadcaster if he intends to do his job with integrity. Here's why I feel that way.

First, fans want to know what caused that goal. A fan wants a former player’s perspective on all the elements that directly led to that specific goal being scored. Former broadcaster, turned team president, John Davidson once offered me some great advice. “Focus on the notable stuff, and always try to tell them why that just happened.”

That’s the part that might escape the eye of even a seasoned hockey fan. What a fan doesn’t want, on the other hand, is for the color analyst to simply repackage the comments that his play-by-play man made as the goal was scored. There’s nothing very insightful or interesting about that.

Second, hockey fans are a sophisticated bunch. They appreciate the finer points in the game. For that reason, if a broadcaster consistently avoids calling out the hometown player when the player “boots it”, you tend to lose credibility with your audience. I cannot tell you how often Tom and I hear from our listeners on this very point. They appreciate that we call the good and the bad in spite of the fact that we work closely with the players.

Lastly, let me make two simple points. No one is perfect and it’s almost always possible to deliver criticism in an even-handed way. Players and fans realize that it’s a long and demanding season and every player is going to have the occasional ‘lowlight’ to go along with the many bright spots. When the unfortunate does happen, a broadcaster, by way of the tone in his voice and the words he chooses, can still break down the play and tell the fans what they need to hear without hanging a player out to dry. Makes sense, no?

See you around the rink.

In order to view this page you need JavaScript and Flash Player 9+ support!




1 z - ANA 82 54 20 8 266 209 116
2 y - COL 82 52 22 8 250 220 112
3 x - STL 82 52 23 7 248 191 111
4 x - SJS 82 51 22 9 249 200 111
5 x - CHI 82 46 21 15 267 220 107
6 x - LAK 82 46 28 8 206 174 100
7 x - MIN 82 43 27 12 207 206 98
8 x - DAL 82 40 31 11 235 228 91
9 PHX 82 37 30 15 216 231 89
10 NSH 82 38 32 12 216 242 88
11 WPG 82 37 35 10 227 237 84
12 VAN 82 36 35 11 196 223 83
13 CGY 82 35 40 7 209 241 77
14 EDM 82 29 44 9 203 270 67


S. Weber 79 23 33 -2 56
P. Hornqvist 76 22 31 1 53
C. Smith 79 24 28 16 52
M. Fisher 75 20 29 -4 49
R. Josi 72 13 27 -2 40
M. Cullen 77 10 29 4 39
C. Wilson 81 11 22 -1 33
N. Spaling 71 13 19 2 32
R. Ellis 80 6 21 9 27
G. Bourque 74 9 17 -5 26
C. Hutton 20 11 4 .910 2.62
D. Dubnyk 11 18 3 .891 3.43 is the official Web site of the Nashville Predators and are trademarks of the Nashville Predators.  NHL, the NHL Shield, the word mark and image of the Stanley Cup and NHL Conference logos are registered trademarks of the National Hockey League. All NHL logos and marks and NHL team logos and marks as well as all other proprietary materials depicted herein are the property of the NHL and the respective NHL teams and may not be reproduced without the prior written consent of NHL Enterprises, L.P. Copyright © 1999-2013 Nashville Predators and the National Hockey League. All Rights Reserved.

NHL Ticket Exchange | Bridgestone Arena | Contact Us | Employment | Terms of Use | Site Map | AdChoices